I'm sick of Hollywood reboots. Spider-man, Robocop, Time Cop, The A-Team, etc. I understand the marketing appeal—these are stories that come with a built-in audience—but, for me, it's beginning to have the opposite effect. These days, I avoid seeing a reboot unless it is exceptional. It's simply been overdone and it achieves nothing.
Hollywood: why not build on the franchises? Why not use the material that is already there?
So what if you have a new actor to play Spider-Man? So what if you want to change a few details—do we really need to have that lame spider-bite story retold all over again for no reason? Every cartoon, comic, movie adaptation—the spider-bite has been told and re-told too many times. It is, simply, boring. At the very least, you could have given us a two-minute recap of the story and then plowed forward into new territory. (And the first of the reboot movies lacked emotional depth, horrible acting, plot holes, questionable special effects ... so I have no plans on seeing this summer's version, no matter what the trailers look like.)
With a few tweaks any of the forthcoming stories could build on the existing tales without the need for extensive recapping or retelling.
But Hollywood is run by businessmen, not creators. Originality and quality are a by-product, not the product.
From the writer's perspective, all this stuff we do comes down to one thing: keep the reader reading. If the reader doesn't keep reading, we've just wasted a bunch of time. Now, sure, we can say the writer benefits too. Many writers say they would write even knowing nobody would ever read their work. I'm not disputing this, but writers do what they do hoping someone else will read their work.
Keeping that one thing in mind, I see two aspects: keeping the reader reading right now, and making the reader come back for more later (for longer fiction, anyway.)
Keeping the Reader Reading
I could go into all kinds of thing here, but the one thing I want to focus on is conflict. It isn't some kind of magic. In fact, it's quite basic: someone isn't happy and something is in the way.
Bringing the Reader Back
Not surprisingly, this is related to the first thing. If conflict can keep them reading, it can bring them back, too. But we can only write about one thing at a time, right? So the solution is simple: we promise further conflict. That promise is what I call tension.
Any new writer will hear the advice to always have conflict. Every scene, every paragraph, every sentence, every word should be rife with tension. The problem I ran into was that it didn't work. It led to forced, contrived, tiresome scenes, paragraphs, sentences and words.
Until someone added that one simple element: the promise of conflict. It's still not easy, but things worked out better for me at that point.
Taking that further, one could even find a certain rhythm in the ebb and flow of conflict and tension, if one were so inclined.
So what about scenes that promise conflict, but don't contain any immediate conflict right now? Can they work? Yes. I call them incidents (a term borrowed from a fellow writer, but not an uncommon term in writing.) Incident leads to impact, and that impact is what brings the reader back. A car accident might have conflict: the paramedics are trying to save dad's life. But suppose we took that out—just a car accident. Sure, I might weave some other things in or just have it in the background. There's no need to drag an incident out, but it leaves questions hanging: what will happen to the kids now? Who gets the inheritance money?
Because of the ancient and unquestionable advice to always have conflict at every moment, some writers balk at this idea. It's not hard to find examples in classic literature, though. Gandolf shows up on Bilbo's doorstep. They don't argue or draw swords, but Gandolf's appearance promises trouble ahead for our little hero. The same is true of the rich heiress walking into the detective's office, or Katniss volunteering as tribute. She doesn't argue with the guards or struggle against inner demons, she simply does what is right and, in so doing, promises us that conflict is ahead.
Writer of speculative fiction. Current work in progress is an untitled dark fantasy novella.